Long Island Watch Reviews

Long Island Watch has an overall rating of 4.5 based on 138 reviews. Customer feedback on Long Island Watch is mixed: Long Island Watch reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of watches, competitive pricing, excellent customer service, fast shipping, which strongly appeal to watch enthusiasts, collectors, casual buyers, gift shoppers. However, Long Island Watch is often criticized for its limited international shipping options, occasional stock issues, website navigation can be confusing, higher prices on some brands.

4.5/5.0

138 reviews

5 Stars

18

4 Stars

1

3 Stars

4

2 Stars

1

1 Star

0

All Long Island Watch Reviews (138)
alma_Stinson01
May 14, 2026
"Pretty good regulation on my SKX"
My SKX seems to be running a lot better now, and the amplitude looked solid from what I could tell. Shipping was quick too, maybe just a couple days or so. Overall, I’m happy with it
Gerald.edwards
May 08, 2026
"Pretty much what I expected"
Everything went smoothly with no issues. I already had a feeling it would be a hassle-free experience, and this pretty much confirmed that for me.
david_Izzo04
April 27, 2026
"Right away, Marc came across as honest and..."
Right away, Marc came across as honest and upfront, which made a big difference for me. He was clear about the watches and how he runs the business, without any pushy or weird sales talk. My first impression was that he’s someone you can actually trust, and that matters a lot to me.
AnnGrove
April 23, 2026
"I went into this with low expectations…"
I went into this with low expectations, but wow, I was not prepared. It completely surprised me in the best way and ended up being much better than I expected.
ElliotThurmond
April 22, 2026
"Their watch videos literally helped so much"
I came across longislandwatch.com through their YouTube videos, and they literally helped me understand watches way better. Marc explains everything in such a normal, easygoing way, not like he’s just rattling off specs or trying too hard to sound fancy.
After watching a bunch of the videos, I felt a lot more confident about what I actually wanted to buy. The website was easy to use too, so the whole experience was really smooth. Definitely a 5-star experience for me.
victor-Wright
April 18, 2026
"The box came looking neat and was packed…"
The box came looking neat and was packed safely enough. I remember thinking, okay, good, nothing looks crushed or messy, so that was a relief. Simple, but it did the job...
rose1998
March 29, 2026
"Great fit right out of the box"
They actually helped me figure out the right bracelet size before shipping, which made a big difference. The watch showed up fitting really well and I barely had to adjust anything. Compared to other places I’ve ordered from, where you kind of have to guess and deal with sizing after the fact, this was a much smoother experience.
WILLIAMS
March 26, 2026
"They did help me out in…"
They did help me out in the end, which I appreciated, but the replies, took longer than I expected
CarolynBeckett_37
March 21, 2026
"Quick and Easy to Find Things"
I was able to find what I needed really fast because everything was easy to search through and laid out clearly. It saved me time, so the whole experience felt simple and stress-free...
Clark_moreno89
March 16, 2026
"Order Was Correct"
Everything matched my order, so there weren’t any issues in the end. I was expecting that I might have to ask for an apology if something was missing or wrong, but it all arrived as it should.
RATLIFF
March 15, 2026
"Shipping was faster then I thought"
I ordered a watch from longislandwatch.com and it shipped out way quicker than I was expecting. Got the tracking the same day too, which was kinda surprising cause I figured it might take a bit.

The package showed up in just a couple days and everything was packed good. No delays, no having to email anyone or chase for updates. Easy order all around, I’d buy from them again...
RichardNewton_86
March 14, 2026
"The watch looks authentic and it did…"
The watch looks authentic and it did come with the right box and cards, which I’m happy about. But i was a little annoyed that I still felt like I had to double-check the serial number myself. The site is fine overall, I just wish they were more clear upfront about the authenticity details so you’re not left second-guessing.
MAHAR
March 11, 2026
"Specs were spot on"
Everything matched my watch exactly, just like it said. No surprises at all, which was nice.
Ramon.marashio
March 10, 2026
"Customer service felt a bit slow"
I don’t know why, but it took a while to get replies from customer service. Nothing major, just felt kinda slow when I needed help...
janice1999
March 06, 2026
"Super Easy Exchange"
I had to do an exchange the whole process was super easy. Everything went smoothly, and based on my experience, it was way more hassle-free than I expected. Really happy with how simple they made it.
juanrodriguez7854
February 27, 2026
"Parts didn’t really fit my mod"
I picked these up thinking they’d work with my mod, but the compatibility info wasn’t exactly not confusing. Once I tried installing them, the parts just didn’t line up right, so it was a bit frustrating.
Francis.porter
February 26, 2026
"Yep, the Islander look won me over fast"
I liked the Islander style pretty much the second I saw it. Clean, simple design, and after wearing it a bit, it actually feels better than I expected
gilbertsvendsen6875
January 26, 2026
"Feels like buying from actual watch people"
I was in a relaxed mood when I was browsing around, and I was reminded why I like Long Island Watch so much. They actually stay connected with the watch community online and answer questions like real people. Marc comes across really down to earth, not like some random faceless store, and that makes me feel a lot more comfortable buying from them
Debra_haley94
January 22, 2026
"Nice watch, but that customs stuff was annoying"
I ordered it from overseas and the watch itself showed up in good shape, so no complaints there. The customs fees and the wait were more than I was expecting though, and that whole part was kind of a hassle. Not really on them, just one of those things I guess.
hello_virginia555
January 17, 2026
"They kept me updated the whole time and..."
They kept me updated the whole time and replied really fast. it was almost too easy, like someone behind the scenes actually had everything under control for once. No guessing, no weird silence, just a simple order that went smoothly

View More Reviews

Have a question about Long Island Watch?
longislandwatch

Long Island Watch Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.